Test of Benchmark Quality
SAMURAI The choice of benchmark often has a significant effect on the assessment of manager performance. Investment managers should be compared only with benchmarks that reflect the universe of securities available to them. A valid benchmark must satisfy certain criteria….
Asset-Based Benchmarks
The seven types of benchmarks introduced in this section are Absolute (including target) return benchmarks. Broad market indexes. Style indexes. Factor-model-based benchmarks. Returns-based (Sharpe style analysis) benchmarks. Manager universes (peer groups). Custom security-based (strategy) benchmarks. Absolute Return Benchmark An absolute…
Liability-Based Benchmarks
Liability-based benchmarks are created from the perspective of cash flow needs. The cash flow needed from the assets in order to fund a future liability is the focus. Using this metric, managers can see how much of a particular liability…
Return Attribution Analysis
Results Attributable to the Investment Manager Those results due to the decision of the investment manager are also known as Micro attribution. This analysis involves understanding the drivers of a manager's returns and whether those drivers are consistent with the…
Risk Attribution Approach
Risk attribution identifies the sources of risk in portfolios. For absolute mandates, it identifies the sources of portfolio volatility. For benchmark-relative mandates, it identifies the sources of tracking risk. (e.g., portfolio volatility or tracking risk). $$ \textbf{Type of Attribution Analysis}…
Fixed-Income Return Attribution
Factor-Based Return Attribution Factors refer to a driver of returns. There are myriad of investment factors in existence and many models with which to capture them and use them to decompose returns. The curriculum reviews the Carhart 4-Factor Model. This…
Sources of Portfolio Returns
Simple Attribution Return attribution approaches are a way to break down the returns of a portfolio and determine where they came from. They can be highly informative for all stakeholders from portfolio managers to clients. The simplest form of return…
Return-Based, Holdings-Based and Transaction-Based Performance Attribution
Performance attribution may be either returns-based, holdings-based, or transactions based. The decision to use one set of inputs rather than another depends on the availability of data as well as the investment process being measured. Returns-based Attribution In returns-based attribution,…
Performance Attribution Components
Performance attribution includes both the return attribution and the risk attribution, not just that of the performance. Return attribution analyzes the impact of active investment decisions on returns, not passive returns. Risk attribution analyzes the risk consequences of those active…
Effective Attribution Process
Numerous stakeholders are interested in the results of the performance attribution process. Virtually any individual or entity that is affected by the outcomes of the portfolio should want to know how the return (or loss) was achieved. What specific decision…